Witness Evaluation Typologies
by
Michael W. Decaire HBSc (candidate)
Forensic Psychology is a diverse and ever-growing
discipline. Forensic psychologist has consistently been at the forefront
of the field of social-legal psychology. The social-legal psychologist
performs a number of essential functions within the common law court system..
One function of the social-legal psychologist is the evaluation of potential
witnesses. By categorizing a particular witness one can predetermine,
to an extent, what to expect from that individual in future encounters.
A number of different typologies exist. The Crime Classification
Manual (1992) makes a number of witness type distinctions:
-
The Distraught Witness - The distraught witness bears a great deal of
emotional distress. This distress is the direct result of either
witnessing the crime or indirectly from their relationship with the
victim.
-
The Fraudulent Witness - While not having any first hand knowledge of
the crime, the fraudulent witness is an active attention seeker whom comes
forward to offer fraudulent evidence.
-
The Hostile Witness - This witness is deliberately antagonistic and/or
noncompliant. Such an individual may invent facts in order to purposefully
mislead the law. The hostile witness may react this way for two reasons:
(1) their relationship to the offender, or (2) a underlying animosity towards
the law.
-
The Intimidated Witness - This witness fears retaliation from the offender(s)
involved or from the criminal element in general. As a result, the
intimidated witness is quite apprehensive.
-
The Inventive Witness - These witnesses typically embellish and create
details when being interviewed. This is likely due to an inability
to differentiate between fantasy and reality. They may also have
esteem motives, in that they wish to appear important.
-
The Reluctant Witness - Witness responds with reluctance due to a natural
restraint that is a reflection of their personality. This particular
witness will be hesitant and reserved. They will not find it easy
to talk freely. Others may feel that the act they have witnessed
is "none of their business".
Douglas, J. E., Burgess, A. W., Burgess, A. G.,
& Ressler, R. K. (1992). Crime Classification Manual.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.